| Name | City | State | Division | Region |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anderson University | Anderson | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Ball State University | Muncie | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| Bethel University | Mishawaka | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Butler University | Indianapolis | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| DePauw University | Greencastle | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Earlham College | Richmond | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Franklin College | Franklin | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Goshen College | Goshen | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Grace College | Winona Lake | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Hanover College | Hanover | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Holy Cross College | Notre Dame | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Huntington University | Huntington | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Indiana Tech | Fort Wayne | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Indiana University | Bloomington | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| Indiana University East | Richmond | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Indiana University Northwest | Gary | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Indiana University Southeast | New Albany | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis | Indianapolis | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| Indiana Wesleyan University | Marion | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Manchester University | North Manchester | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Marian University | Indianapolis | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| Oakland City University | Oakland City | Indiana | NCAA II | Midwest |
| Purdue Northwest University-Calumet Campus | Hammond | Indiana | NCAA II | Midwest |
| Purdue University | West Lafayette | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Terre Haute | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| Trine University | Angola | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |
| University of Indianapolis | Indianapolis | Indiana | NCAA II | Midwest |
| University of Notre Dame | Notre Dame | Indiana | NCAA I | Midwest |
| University of Saint Francis | Fort Wayne | Indiana | NAIA | Midwest |
| University of Southern Indiana | Evansville | Indiana | NCAA II | Midwest |
| Wabash College | Crawfordsville | Indiana | NCAA III | Midwest |